Old-Fashioned Peanut Butter Fudge

Line the pan and sift the powdered sugar before the saucepan goes on the stove. The brown sugar syrup needs a two-minute boil, and everything moves quickly after that. Once you’ve stirred in the peanut butter, a hand mixer brings the syrup and powdered sugar together into a thick fudge you can spread straight into the pan.

Brown sugar gives this old-fashioned peanut butter fudge its caramel flavor. Salted butter keeps the sweetness in check, and creamy peanut butter gives each piece a smooth center. The stovetop part goes quickly, so the hardest part is leaving the pan alone long enough to set.

Make it before you start the rest of your holiday baking or the night before you fill a candy tin. Once it’s cool, the slab lifts out by the parchment and cuts into small squares for sharing.

What goes into old-fashioned peanut butter fudge?

This recipe uses two sugars, each for a different job. Packed brown sugar cooks with whole milk and salted butter to make the base. Sifted powdered sugar goes in after cooking and thickens the fudge as you beat it. Measure the two sugars separately so you can move straight from the stove to the mixing bowl.

Choose a smooth, regular creamy peanut butter that’s ready to scoop from the jar. A natural peanut butter with a layer of oil on top can change how firmly the fudge sets. Stir the peanut butter and vanilla into the hot syrup after you take the pan off the heat.

How to make peanut butter fudge on the stove

Fit parchment into an 8×8-inch pan, leaving enough paper at the sides to lift the fudge later. If you use foil, butter the side that touches the fudge. Sift the powdered sugar into a large heat-safe bowl and set it within reach.

Stir the brown sugar, whole milk, and salted butter in a medium saucepan over medium-high heat. Give the sugar time to dissolve as the mixture heats, then start the two-minute timer once it reaches a steady boil. Take the pan off the burner and stir in the peanut butter and vanilla until smooth.

Pour the warm mixture over the powdered sugar and beat with a hand mixer until the white streaks and lumps disappear. Scrape it into the lined pan, smooth the top, and give it about three hours at room temperature. Lift the cooled slab onto a cutting board and slice it into a six-by-six grid for 36 pieces.

Tips for smooth fudge that slices cleanly

Check the texture before it sets. Grit in the syrup points to brown sugar that hasn’t fully dissolved. White flecks in the finished mixture are usually powdered sugar clumps. Sifting ahead and beating until the mixture looks even address those two problems at different stages.

Wait for the middle to cool. The edges can feel firm while the center is still soft. When the entire slab has cooled, cut straight down with a sharp knife and wipe the blade between cuts.

Make-ahead and storage

Pack cooled fudge in an airtight container and refrigerate it. Slip parchment between layers to keep the squares separate, especially if you’re filling a gift tin. To freeze it, wrap the cooled fudge tightly in plastic wrap and then foil. Freeze for up to two months for best quality and thaw it in the refrigerator.

Do I need a candy thermometer?

A kitchen timer is enough for this version. Start timing when the milk, butter, and brown sugar reach a steady boil, then take the saucepan off the heat after two minutes. For a different stovetop method with fewer ingredients, see Bestfeed’s four-ingredient peanut butter fudge.

Old-Fashioned Peanut Butter Fudge Recipe

Hands breaking open a creamy peanut butter fudge square above more fudge on parchment paper
Bestfeed

Old-Fashioned Peanut Butter Fudge

Creamy stovetop peanut butter fudge made with a quick brown sugar syrup and sifted powdered sugar. Let it set at room temperature before cutting it into 36 squares.
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 3 hours 15 minutes
Servings: 36 pieces

Ingredients
  

  • 2 cups packed brown sugar
  • ¾ cup whole milk
  • ½ cup salted butter
  • 1 cup peanut butter
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 3 cups sifted powdered sugar

Method
 

  1. Line an 8×8-inch pan with parchment, leaving an overhang for lifting. If you prefer a foil sling, butter the foil. Sift the powdered sugar into a large heat-safe bowl.
  2. Put the brown sugar, whole milk, and salted butter in a medium saucepan over medium-high heat. Stir frequently while the butter melts and the sugar dissolves.
  3. Once the mixture reaches a steady boil, time it for 2 minutes, then take the saucepan off the heat.
  4. Stir the peanut butter and vanilla into the hot syrup until the mixture looks smooth.
  5. Pour the peanut butter mixture over the sifted powdered sugar. Beat with a hand mixer until no pockets of dry sugar remain.
  6. Spread the fudge in the lined pan and leave it at room temperature for about 3 hours to firm up.
  7. Once the fudge has cooled all the way through, lift it out by the liner and cut it into 36 squares.

Notes

The total includes 3 hours of setting time. Start the 2-minute timer once the brown sugar mixture boils. Creamy peanut butter with no separated oil works best.