Monterey Sausage Pie

Sunday mornings in my home have a familiar rhythm. Coffee brewing, natural light streaming through my kitchen windows, and more often than not, this Monterey Sausage Pie in the oven. I stumbled across this recipe during a weekend when I had friends staying over and wanted something that could feed everyone without keeping me away from the conversation.

After several attempts (and many willing taste-testers), I’ve perfected what has become one of my most requested breakfast dishes. There’s something magical about the way the savory sausage pairs with the creamy egg mixture and melty cheese—it’s comfort food that somehow feels special enough for company but simple enough for a lazy Sunday.

The Secret to Its Success

What makes this sausage pie so beloved in my household isn’t fancy ingredients or complicated techniques—it’s the perfect balance of textures and flavors. The base layer of seasoned sausage provides a savory foundation, while the cheesy egg mixture bakes into something between a quiche and a souffle.

I’ve made this recipe at least a dozen times, and I’ve found that taking a few extra minutes to properly drain the sausage makes all the difference. The first time I made it, I rushed this step and ended up with a slightly greasy pie. Now I know better—those small details matter.

What You’ll Need

Bulk pork sausage: I prefer using a medium-spiced breakfast sausage, though Italian sausage works beautifully when I’m craving something with more herbs. If you’re watching fat content, turkey sausage is a lighter option I’ve tested successfully.

Monterey Jack cheese: This cheese melts perfectly into the pie, adding creaminess without overwhelming the other flavors. I’ve found that freshly shredded cheese melts much better than pre-packaged options.

Sharp cheddar cheese: The sharpness adds a wonderful contrast to the mild Monterey Jack. I’ve experimented with extra-sharp varieties when I want a more pronounced cheese flavor.

Onion: Finely chopped yellow onion adds sweetness and depth. When I’m short on time, I’ve used shallots instead for a milder flavor profile.

Green bell pepper: This adds color and a fresh element to balance the richness. I make this optional because my daughter prefers it without, and the recipe works beautifully either way.

Eggs: These provide structure and richness. I always use large eggs at room temperature for the most consistent results.

Half-and-half: Creates a silky texture in the custard. I’ve used whole milk in a pinch, but the half-and-half truly makes it special.

All-purpose flour: Just enough to give the egg mixture structure without making it heavy.

Baking powder: A little lift makes the texture light rather than dense—a trick I learned from my grandmother.

Salt and black pepper: I season with a light hand since the sausage and cheese already contribute saltiness.

Green onions or chives: Not just a pretty garnish—they add a fresh, bright finish that cuts through the richness.

Let’s Get Cooking

Brown the Sausage Base

I start by cooking the sausage in my cast iron skillet, breaking it into crumbles as it browns. Taking the time to drain it well prevents the final pie from becoming greasy—a lesson I learned the hard way during early test batches. When I’m cooking for my vegetarian friends, I’ve successfully substituted plant-based crumbles with a sprinkle of fennel seeds and a dash of smoked paprika to mimic that sausage flavor.

Build the Flavor Foundation

In the same skillet (because those browned bits are flavor gold), I sauté the onions and bell peppers until they soften and just start to caramelize at the edges. This step develops sweetness that balances the savory elements. The kitchen starts to fill with the most inviting aroma at this point—something I look forward to every time I make this recipe.

Layer with Love

I’ve found that layering the ingredients rather than mixing them together creates distinct pockets of flavor in every bite. The sausage forms a perfect base, followed by the sautéed vegetables and then that generous blanket of two cheeses. Sometimes I can’t resist sneaking a little extra cheese—a habit my husband heartily endorses.

Create the Custard

Whisking the eggs with half-and-half creates the silky custard that brings everything together. The addition of flour and baking powder might seem unusual, but it’s what gives this pie its unique texture—somewhere between a quiche and a souffle. I learned this technique from an old cookbook I found at my grandmother’s house, and it’s made all the difference.

The Magic in the Oven

As the pie bakes, my kitchen fills with an aroma that inevitably draws everyone to the table. I’ve discovered that 35 minutes is perfect in my oven, but I always check by inserting a knife in the center—it should come out clean, and the top should be golden with a slight wobble in the very center.

Make It Your Own

When I’m hosting a brunch with my college friends, I add a layer of sautéed mushrooms and fresh thyme—an addition inspired by a memorable breakfast we shared during a weekend trip to wine country.

For weeknight dinners, I often add a handful of baby spinach to the vegetable mixture. It wilts perfectly into the pie, adding color and nutrients without changing the texture significantly.

Last Christmas morning, I made a version with diced ham instead of sausage and added a pinch of nutmeg to the egg mixture—it was the perfect accompaniment to gift opening and became an instant holiday tradition.

My Best Tips

The cheese makes all the difference in this recipe. I’ve found that taking an extra minute to grate it myself rather than using pre-shredded varieties results in a much creamier melt without the anti-caking agents.

Don’t rush the cooling time after baking. I’ve learned (sometimes impatiently) that allowing the pie to rest for at least 5 minutes helps it set properly for clean slices.

The pie reheats beautifully, which makes it perfect for meal prep. I often make it on Sunday and enjoy slices throughout the busy week—20 seconds in the microwave brings it back to life.

If your pie starts browning too quickly but isn’t set in the middle, loosely cover it with foil for the remaining bake time—a trick my mother taught me that I use constantly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make this ahead of time? → Absolutely! I often assemble it the night before, cover and refrigerate, then bake in the morning. Just add about 5-10 minutes to the baking time if it’s coming straight from the refrigerator.

How do I know when it’s done? → A knife inserted in the center should come out clean, and the top should be golden brown. A slight jiggle in the very center is fine—it will set as it cools.

Can I freeze leftovers? → Yes, I’ve frozen individual slices wrapped in parchment then foil. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator and reheat gently in the microwave or oven.

What can I serve with this? → I love pairing it with a simple green salad dressed with lemon vinaigrette. The brightness balances the richness perfectly.

Can I make this in a different size pan? → I’ve successfully made this in a 9×13 baking dish—just increase the ingredients by about 50% and check for doneness around the 40-minute mark.

Print