Set half the shredded cheese aside before you start the sauce. In this five-cheese baked mac and cheese, the reserved cheese goes in two places: between layers of sauced macaroni and across the top. The middle stays creamy, and the top browns into a crust you can break with the edge of a serving spoon.
This is a Thanksgiving side you can bake while the turkey rests. The milk and cream make a smooth base for sharp cheddar, Colby Jack, medium cheddar, mozzarella and Gruyère. The most important part happens at the stove. Once the sauce thickens slightly, turn off the burner before stirring in the cheese.
What each cheese does
Sharp cheddar gives the sauce its bite, and medium cheddar adds more cheddar flavor with a gentler finish. Colby Jack brings a mild, buttery taste. Mozzarella gives the middle layer its stretch. Gruyère, used in a smaller amount, adds a nutty note that comes through under the broiled top.
Combine the five cheeses in one bowl before you start cooking. It makes it easier to split the blend evenly among the sauce, middle and topping. Grating the cheese ahead is also the easiest bit of Thanksgiving prep to get out of the way. Keep it covered in the fridge until you’re ready to cook.
How to make five-cheese baked mac and cheese
Drain the elbows while they still have a little bite
Boil the elbow macaroni in salted water for about six minutes. Taste an elbow before draining. It should still feel firm in the middle. The pasta will soften further in the oven, and an elbow that’s already tender at the stove can go soft by the time the top browns.
Make the sauce in the pasta pot
Whisk flour into melted butter over medium-low heat and stir for two to three minutes. The mixture should stay pale. Stir the garlic powder, onion powder, ground mustard, paprika, pepper and salt into the butter and flour before adding the dairy.
Pour the whole milk in gradually while whisking to work out any lumps. Add the heavy cream and let the mixture thicken gently without boiling. Take the pot off the heat as soon as the base is slightly thickened. The cheese will add more body, so there’s no need to cook the dairy down to a thick paste.
Turn off the heat before adding the cheese
Add half the shredded cheese a handful at a time and stir until it melts into the warm sauce. Adding the cheese off the heat helps keep the sauce smooth. A hard boil can leave it grainy or oily. Stir in the drained macaroni once the sauce is smooth enough to coat it evenly.
Layer the macaroni and finish the top under the broiler
Spread half the macaroni in a greased 9-by-13-inch baking dish and scatter half the reserved cheese over it. Add the rest of the macaroni, then finish with the remaining cheese. This is a generous batch. Choose a deep dish and leave a little room at the rim. If your dish is shallow, bake any extra in a second dish.
Bake at 350°F for 15 to 20 minutes, until the center is hot and the cheese on top has melted. For a browned top, broil on high for two to three minutes in a broiler-safe dish. Stay by the oven. The cheese can go from spotted and bubbling to burnt in a short time.
Serving it at Thanksgiving
Shred the cheese and portion the seasonings ahead so you can make the sauce and assemble the pan while the turkey rests. If you’re sharing the oven with another side, get the mac and cheese fully hot before switching to the broiler. For the rest of the menu, try crispy crème brûlée sweet potatoes or make the pineapple and coconut pecan pie ahead for dessert.
Storing and reheating leftovers
Transfer leftovers to shallow containers and refrigerate within two hours, or within one hour above 90°F. Use refrigerated leftovers within three to four days. Reheat individual portions, covered, until they reach 165°F throughout. Covering the dish helps keep the edges from drying out. USDA storage guidance and reheating guidance.
Frequently asked questions
Why did my cheese sauce turn grainy?
The dairy may have been too hot when the cheese went in. Turn the heat off first and add the cheese gradually. Once it melts, fold in the pasta and let the oven finish the dish.
How much cheese goes between the layers?
Use one-quarter of the full cheese blend in the middle and one-quarter on top. The other half goes into the sauce. Dividing the shreds before you start makes the layers easy to remember.
Can I skip broiling the mac and cheese?
Yes. Serve it once the center is hot and the top cheese has melted. Broiling is only for the browned crust.
Five-Cheese Baked Mac and Cheese Recipe

Five-Cheese Baked Mac and Cheese
Ingredients
Method
- Boil the elbow macaroni in salted water for about 6 minutes, just shy of al dente. Drain and set aside. It will finish cooking in the oven.
- In the same pot, melt the butter over medium-low heat. Whisk in the flour and cook for 2–3 minutes, stirring constantly and keeping the mixture pale. Stir in the seasonings.
- Slowly whisk in the whole milk until smooth, followed by the heavy cream. Cook for 5–8 minutes, stirring frequently, until warmed through and slightly thickened. Do not let it boil.
- Turn off the heat. Gradually stir in half of the combined shredded cheeses until melted and smooth. Keep the other half for layering.
- Fold the macaroni into the sauce until coated. In a greased 9×13-inch baking dish, layer half the macaroni, half the reserved cheese, the remaining macaroni, and the remaining cheese.
- Bake at 350°F for 15–20 minutes, until hot and the cheese is melted. For a browned crust, broil on high for 2–3 minutes in a broiler-safe dish, watching closely.





